Zappos lets you return your shoes for a full year. Of course some people abuse that. Tony Hsieh never pretended otherwise. In Delivering Happiness he writes that about 2% of customers send their shoes back after a year, so they had a full year of free shoes. Zappos kept the policy anyway, because the other 98% buy with more confidence, come back, and tell their friends. The cheaters are a cost of doing business. The trust is the business.
Most companies do the opposite.
About 2% of your customers will rip you off. They will game your system. They will lie to you. Pretend they’re angry. Refuse to pay. Complain in public, just to put you under pressure. Ask to speak to your boss, and whether you know who they are. You get the idea.
Who are your rules for?
In 2011 I bought a ticket to Brussels from an NMBS machine at Gent station. I paid by card. The machine failed to print and went out of order. At the counter, the employee said he couldn’t help me and couldn’t refund me. He gave me a complaint form for head office.
He could see the out-of-order screen from his counter. I had bought tickets from him at least fifteen times that year. There aren’t many Dutch people buying a ticket to Amsterdam at six in the morning every week. None of it counted. Somewhere, a rule had been written for the 2%, and he had to apply it to me.
What does distrust cost the honest 98%?
More than you think. Treat every customer like a possible cheat and you don’t stop the 2%. You teach the 98% that the relationship is a negotiation. So they start negotiating too.
It doesn’t have to be this way.
- Zappos: 365 days to return your shoes. Read the full case.
- Café René, my favourite bar in Gent: on the terrace you pay when you leave, not per round. Some people walk off without paying, or pay too little. Paying at the end is still so much nicer on a terrace that it wins. And I bet people order one more round when nobody puts the bill in front of them.
- Insurers that fix first and ask later: when I wrote this in 2011, Interpolis fixed your damage first and sorted out the details afterwards. Some customers will have abused that too. It never outweighed how good it feels when things are handled quickly and without hassle.
Fifteen years later.
Look at self-scanning in the supermarket. You scan your own groceries, bag them, pay and walk out. Nobody checks every item. Some people will cheat, and the shop knows it. So it checks a few customers at random and trusts everyone else. That’s a rule written for the 98%, with a small net for the 2%.
The cheating 2% are your most important customers. They show the difference between companies that act out of fear of losing a little, and companies that see how much they can win with everyone else.
Updated by Polle in October 2026. First published in October 2011. Zappos moved to the front, the book tip went out, and there is a new example from today.
Goes well with: Zappos: 365 days to return it and The $2,000 rule.
