BlogpostsParentingThoughtsVoice

How Amazon Echo made me a worse person

By 17/03/2016 February 5th, 2020 No Comments

Alexa had clearly conditioned me not to talk to her/it, but to command.

Amazon Alexa

Since last week, my family is the proud owner of an Amazon Echo. And we’re extremely happy with that (more on that later in an other post). However, it took me less than 24 hours to notice an interesting by-effect, I hadn’t anticipated: It made me a worse person.

At first, I addressed Alexa more or less like I would address a person: “Alexa, could you please add milk to the shopping list?”“Alexa, can you set a timer for three minutes?”“Alexa, could you play some music please?”“Alexa, can you please turn on the lights?”. But as the the number of times that Alexa wouldn’t understand me accumulated, I got a bit frustrated. It might be the fact that I still have to go through it’s voice training, it might be the fact that my Dutch-English pronunciation is far from ideal, it might be that Alexa and I have to get to know each other; whatever it was, it didn’t work out.

So, I adopted an other approach.

“Alexa, music!”“Alexa, add milk to the shopping list!”, “Alexa, softer!”; a clearly more direct, staccato, directive way of communicating.

And it worked. At least, the number of times Alexa would not understand what I meant decreased dramatically.

And it worked. In the way that Alexa had clearly conditioned me not to talk to her/it, but to command.

And I would rather not. I actually noticed that when I command Alexa on one moment, the next I can’t instantly switch to a friendly conversation. And the other way around: when I’m in the middle of a conversation with my wife, it takes effort for me to switch to a more directive mode towards Alexa.

I would prefer a more conversational interface, a more talkative, less hierarchical relationship. And maybe it’s telling for the state of digital/internet of things right now. We’re still in the ‘command’-phase, slowly moving towards more conversational interfaces.

Until that, I will have to command Alexa. And be a worse person.

Leave a Reply